Opinion: Why Carlos Baleba Could Be a Better Fit for Manchester United Than Camavinga or Manu Koné

Manchester United’s midfield rebuild is gathering pace, but one factor should heavily influence the club’s decision: availability.

As talented as Eduardo Camavinga and Manu Koné are, I’d rather see United move for Carlos Baleba—and Lisandro Martínez’s injury history is a major reason why.

This isn’t a criticism of Martínez. Far from it.

When fit, he’s one of United’s best defenders. His aggression, leadership, and fighting spirit are exactly what every top team needs. He’s a warrior who gives everything for the badge, and I wouldn’t be looking to sell him.

The problem is that football doesn’t reward talent alone—it rewards players who can stay on the pitch.

Martínez has missed significant periods through injury in recent seasons, and now there are fresh concerns after the injury he reportedly suffered during the World Cup final while representing Argentina.

With another demanding campaign ahead, Manchester United simply cannot afford to rely on too many players whose fitness is uncertain.

That’s why Carlos Baleba makes more sense.

United already have Luke Shaw, Mason Mount, and Lisandro Martínez—three important players whose seasons have repeatedly been disrupted by injuries. Bringing in another midfielder with a similar injury record could increase the risk of finding the squad severely weakened during the most crucial stages of the season.

Baleba offers energy, athleticism, physicality, and, most importantly, the potential to be consistently available throughout a long campaign.

Winning trophies isn’t just about having the best players—it’s about having your best players available when it matters most.

For Manchester United, reliability could be just as important as talent this summer.

Do you agree? Should United prioritise Carlos Baleba over Camavinga and Manu Koné, or would you choose one of the other midfielders? Share your thoughts in the comments.