Opinion: Is Lisandro Martínez Becoming Manchester United’s Next Eric Bailly?

Manchester United once placed enormous faith in Eric Bailly. On his day, he was one of the club’s most exciting defenders—aggressive in the tackle, comfortable carrying the ball out from the back, and capable of dominating attackers with his athleticism.

Unfortunately, injuries prevented him from fulfilling that potential. Despite his undeniable quality, United eventually decided to move on because they needed a defender they could rely on throughout an entire season.

Now, some supporters are beginning to ask whether Lisandro Martínez is heading down a similar path.

This is not a criticism of Martínez’s ability. When fit, he remains one of Manchester United’s most influential defenders. His leadership, composure, passing, and fighting spirit have made him a fan favourite since arriving at Old Trafford.

The concern is his availability.

Over the past few seasons, Martínez has suffered a series of injuries that have kept him out for extended periods. Every time he appears ready to build momentum, another setback seems to interrupt his progress.

For a club aiming to compete for the Premier League and major trophies, consistently losing one of its best defenders is a serious problem.

Football at the highest level demands reliability as much as quality. Even the most talented player cannot help the team from the sidelines.

That raises a difficult question for Manchester United’s decision-makers: if Martínez’s injury struggles continue, should the club remain patient, or would it be wiser to invest in a defender who can be available for most of the season?

It’s a conversation no supporter wants to have because everyone recognises what Martínez brings when he’s fit.

For now, the hope is that he can finally put his injury problems behind him and enjoy a consistent run of games. But if the setbacks continue, United may eventually face the same difficult decision they once made with Eric Bailly.

What do you think? Should Manchester United continue to back Lisandro Martínez, or should the club consider signing a more consistently available centre-back? Share your thoughts in the comments.