Paul Scholes issues warning on carlos Baleba
Paul Scholes Questions Manchester United’s Pursuit of Carlos Baleba
Manchester United legend Paul Scholes has expressed doubts over the club’s reported interest in Brighton midfielder Carlos Baleba, warning that the Cameroonian could be a risky investment at the price being discussed.
According to Scholes, Baleba’s talent is undeniable, but his performances for Brighton last season were too inconsistent to justify an £80–100 million transfer fee.
«”Carlos Baleba is a much bigger risk than many United fans are willing to admit,” Scholes said.»
He argued that Baleba struggled to consistently adapt to Fabian Hürzeler’s tactical demands at Brighton, raising concerns about whether he could immediately cope with the even greater pressure and expectations at Old Trafford.
Rather than paying a huge guaranteed fee, Scholes believes United should negotiate a deal with a lower upfront payment and include performance-related bonuses to reduce the financial risk.
Despite his concerns, Scholes acknowledged that Baleba possesses enormous potential, insisting the midfielder has a very high ceiling—but only if Manchester United sign him at the right price.
The comments have sparked debate among supporters, with some agreeing that Baleba remains a raw talent, while others believe he has the qualities to become a dominant Premier League midfielder under the right coaching.
